While our premium homemade ice creams have some unusual sounding names (Ditch Tea Delight anyone?), their descriptions may be just enough to get you down to our Ice Cream Shoppe for a visit!

While you're here you can enjoy a tasty bite to eat with a cold glass of milk or other refreshment, browse our book offerings, and stock up on some Hartzler milk and butter. We also carry a select assortment of Amish cheeses and other small novelties.

Hartzler's Ice Cream Shop

  • 5454 Cleveland Road
    Wooster, Ohio 44691
  • 330-345-8190


  • Monday - Saturday: 10 AM - 7 PM
  • Sunday: Noon - 7 PM

Ice Cream Flavors

Hover over a flavor below for a description:

Banana Pudding
Black Cherry
Black Raspberry Cream
Blushing Bessie
Butter Pecan
Cherry Cheese Cake
Chicken Feed
Chocolate Royale
Coconut Almond Fudge
Cookies & Cream
Cookie Dough
Cowboy Crunch
Cow Pies and Cream
Ditch Tea Delight
Farm House
Heifer Trails
Hot Fudge Brownie
Hot Mud
Maple Nut
Mocha Carmel Chip
Mocha Mud
Monkey Business
Raspberry Royal
Orange Dreamsicle
Road Hog
Strawberry Cream
Trip to the Dentist

Our Menu

Ice Cream Specialties

Ice Cream Cakes

Milk Shakes and Malts

Root Beer Floats


Fresh Spring Salads



Frozen Cow Latte - Summer Specialty Item